What about those jackets that have heating elements in them? You can then turn them on and off at will.
Hoping to tap into the collective knowledge. Just started a new role involving potentially cold platforms, warm trains and roasting underground, followed by a walk to the office.
I’m struggling for something that will keep me warm enough, but cool enough, if such a thing is even possible.
Originally purchased an insulated parka & returned as looked like I was at some artic base camp. Purchased a slimmer/lighter one & again decided too much, so returned.
I have a quilted Barbour jacket which is too cold in winter but too warm at the moment & am stripping down to my shirt on the underground.
Am I searching for the impossible, as I cannot seem to find something ticking all the boxes. Tri-climate seemed a possible option, but know the TNF thermobol version is going to be too warm with the inner, as even a cheap joules coat like that was very warm.
Frustrated commuter, and given my first time using a train, dear lord are some people just filthy with vile habits...but please keep on the coat topic. TIA.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
What about those jackets that have heating elements in them? You can then turn them on and off at will.
My kids have always had jack Wolfskin 3 in 1 jackets with fleeces zipped in which seem to work really well the adults version in black or dark blue are smart enough and seem to be pretty well made for the price point.
Jack Wolfskin Men's Iceland 3-in-1 Jacket, Black (Black), S https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B06XHWKK..._HVXWDbJ3GY1JK
Something wool as it regulates temperature. With down you’ll just keep heating up.
Perhaps you should think about a few thin layers rather than relying on one outer coat? An outer coat needs to be waterproof, but I favour a light one with a fleece underneath for cold weather.
Hat and gloves help too, and they’re easy to take on and off.
The best solution is early retirement, I’d recommend it to everyone.
For commuting, I'd only consider a Covert.
Interesting on the wool side of things as had discounted it be the more modern synthetics / 3in1.
Got a short list of 3 TNF jackets to look at that are all 3in1 but will open up to looking back at something more traditional.
I strangely never thought of wool as waterproof due to lanolin, but am guessing n’ that is only up to a point vs something BF like a goretex one.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
You are looking for a 20° comfort zone from one garment, that’s never going to happen.
Whatever you do it’s going to mean shedding a layer when you go from train platform at -2 with windchill to a tube at 16° with high moisture content due to people breathing.
And it needs to be showerproof.
Even the best technical fabric will struggle.
I have loads of coats/jackets and my go-to for winter is a Harris tweed one with a button in liner. It’s still going to be too warm on the tube though.
If I didn’t want to be looking like an outdoors activity centre guide I would maybe look at a trench coat/Mac made of technical fabrics and add a liner/gilet underneath
Arcteryx and UBR do them, not cheap though. There is another Scandinavian brand who do something similar but I can’t remember the name
What are others wearing, must be loads of commuters in a similar situation?
Not sure that shedding/replacing/carrying layers particularly practical on a busy commute.
I had to look that up! Let me get this right, a Covert is the brownish, Crombie type overcoat, with or without a velvet collar?
Agree on wool. In all my years of commuting I’ve used a wool coat. Find temperature control more comfortable when switching from walk, train, walk, tube, walk to place of work. Synthetic, down, outdoor gear, far too hot and slow to cool down when switching.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Light weight Berghaus for me never need much more in Essex or London, maybe a Gilet if it gets really cold.
Yes, correct; I've had one since I was 21. Having eventually arrived at the conclusion that the original one was wearing out rather than still wearing in, its replacement had to be one without a velvet collar thanks to Monsieur Fromage (though, I hasten to add, his isn't actually a Covert - it's missing a few vital details).
I was having the same problem. All my coats were either thin waterproofs, thick padded waterproofs or just casual non-waterproofs. And I travel on the Victoria line - the hottest line ever.
I did some research and settled on a Buffalo Fell jacket. I haven't looked back. It's thin enough to not be boiling on the tube and easily stashed, but plenty warm enough on the cold walk to the station and to work. And made in Sheffield
http://www.buffalosystems.co.uk/prod.../#colourswitch
The other one I wear is a Barbour Fell jacket, but this is warmer and thicker, although not too bad on the tube.
Not sure if it's still available though?
The Buffalo is a clear winner for me.
Living this far north I would recommend a wool jumper with an eVent jacket with pit zips. Or do without the latter and just wear the jumper. Soaking wet they are still warm. That’s probably OTT for desk jockeys though!
This time of year I wear a Guernsey jumper, which gets its final rinse in water with a spoon of almond oil. The only hot place I go is the office 24.8 degrees C. We have women to keep warm!
Loving the veilance coat, but a little on the pricey side for my budget, unfortunately.
Paramo is an amazing jacket, have a friend who swears by his, but a little too 'outdoor pursuit instructor' for me really.
I'm rapidly coming to the view of getting a thin gilet to wear under my quilted Barbour jacket & just seeing how I get on.
I did want to upgrade my joules 'thermoball' for the real deal, but the joules one is often too warm when walking.
Can't decide whether to buy the TNF Zaneck as a weekend parka again or not...I am clearly now over thinking it all; should just buy another watch, much easier!
Last edited by Mj2k; 7th November 2019 at 21:32.
I find my old, heavy leather jacket is perfect in most weathers, unless it’s really hot (rare in Manchester!)
Everyone has their own personal opinions but I really rate the Arcteryx Proton Lt hoody (great durability, insulation and actually breathable) and the Patagonia Isthmus parka (bombproof and loads of pockets)...good luck !
I'm a big fan of layering (as mentioned in previous posts) and like insulated jackets that can be used as midlayer with a waterproof or lightweight windbreaker on top or just on its own when you need more breathability...the Proton is brilliant in this regard and designed for mountaineers and climbers who don't want to overheat yet stay warm.
I've got this.
https://www.marksandspencer.com/funn.../p/clp60266744
Currently I walk around in the cold in it but also wear when in the car. Seems to cover both options without me sweating to death or freezing.
I’ve just got one of these from Moose Knuckles
https://www.mooseknucklescanada.com/...parka-m39mp207
It can be fairly smart or casual, is very water resistant, has a hood and is warm, so far, I’m really pleased with it.
Mission Workshop have a few options that could work. This one may be closest to what you are after but have a look at all their jackets.
https://missionworkshop.com/collecti...nt=25625541641
I have a lot of their stuff and it is all great.
I keep reading this as Goat for commuting.
Sounds like you want something gore Tex and perhaps some layers too as it gets colder.
I wear a North Face Bombay until the temperature gets below freezing. I usually have a t-shirt, shirt and light sweater on underneath and it works fine for most types of weather. Unzipping it on the train is enough to keep cool.
Add a hat, gloves, earmuffs and snood, and I have a toasty, if not stylish, cold-weather get up.
Then I have a heavy Canada Goose parka for sub-zero temps.
I’ve purchased a couple of arcteryx items to try now, one mid layer from Dave, who’s been great via pm & an outer wind proof layer direct. Seems to offer a great combo for what I need, but still need a smarter option for meetings, so will look at the above options.
Thanks again to the forum, some great input to help shape my thinking. Also realise I need a new wool coat, always used to wear one until I lost it in a pub.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I've been rocking a Montane Featherlight Down for the past year. Great for going to work in and casual weekend attire.
https://www.trekkinn.com/outdoor-mou...xoCoa0QAvD_BwE
As has been stated, you'll not find a coat that is suitable for both extremes. Buy a coat that keeps you warm in the cold while wearing a jumper undermeath. Then take it off before getting on the tube.
Can't go too far wrong with wool. I was surprised how waterproof (or should that be resist ?) my woollen pea coat was. Stood in steady rain last night for half an hour or so and it hadn't seeped through. I've worn the same coat on the commute and it is just a case of unbuttoning it when it gets hot on the tube.
Tapatapatapatapatalk
Thread bump...
I just got a Barbour National Trust Trap jacket from JL with the current 20% off specifically for the tube journey into work. Early days but so far so good. The irony that the heating had "issues" at work so it was fecking freezing today did not escape me!!