As an everything day to day proper beater where you can shovel, chop wood, really give no consideration to it, I’d choose a citizen eco drive. In my opinion with any automatic it can never be a true beater.
Now I wear my kemmner seahorse for any day to day thing without any thought... and it shows it... but I’ve now considered yard work a no go place for any automatic.
Perhaps my definition of beater is different than a day to day wearer.