Since birth I have had no/totally zero sense of smell so I don't understand smell, I have a very limited sense of taste, I can differentiate extreme's, mustard and jam for example but if I had ten different jams mixed to the same consistency I would fail to say what each was, I can recognise different textures to a certain extent which helps a little, i'm great to cook for.

So for me a good smell would be a spoon full of honey and a bad smell would be a spoon of mustard :)

So what makes a good after shave ? I ask because its this time of year at least one of my kids will ask if I want any for Christmas.