Hi folks, random lurker making my intro here. I've been into the watch collecting hobby for the past 4 years now, having built up a modest collection of Rolex and Tudor watches with the odd Seiko thrown in for good measure.

I'm in the rare position of being offered both of the special edition Tudor Black Bays from either Harrods and Bucherer.

Which one do you guys think I should get and your reasons for and against each watch?

Background info, I don't already have a Black Bay, nor a Bronze watch. Re-sale value may be something to consider should a grail watch become available down the line, though I'm more of a collector then a flipper and in the Harrods Green Bay I would probably keep longer term.

I really do like the look of both of these watches and can't decide which to get.