Through some especially good luck, I was able to get both a Baby Dreadnought and a Baby Willard recently. I was extremely excited about the Baby Dread, as I have always been enamored of the PRS 2, but could not easily carry off wearing its bulkiness. I figured the Willard would be a good 'backup' diver to try out.
Imagine my surprise when I discovered the Baby Willard was the better (for me) watch! It is stellar - perfect diameter for my tastes, has a blockiness that is reminiscent of the '70s dive watches ( think Eterna or ScubaPro 500), a gorgeous empty space dial, and a certain heft without bulk. Its like a great vintage piece only brand new.
The Baby Dreadnought, on the other hand, is a very nice and well made watch but falls short. It is not at all like a smaller version of the PRS2, and really seems to have a strong DNA connection to the PRS18. The case and bezel in particular remiond me of a PRS18 (in itself a great watch, just not what I was expecting). The choice to not copy the knurling on the bezel edge, for example, nor the case finish, are examples of the disconnect. It may just not be possible to replicate the Dreadnought 'feel' in a smaller size; at any rate, the PRS52 is a lovely watch with tons of character, but might better be named 'Dreadnought Light' to clarify its differences.
I'm still pleased as can be at the Baby Willard and happy for the new offerings in general!
Attachment 18263