Originally Posted by
pete-r
I think for me the reason some are underwhelmed is down to two things.
The watches are weaker than some rivals in some features or areas that people assign the term quality to like anti reflection, lume, weight etc. If you asked a watch noob to rank a debadged Daytona, Spitfire chrono, speedie, JLC Polaris or el primero, I suspect they rolex wouldn't be placed as the best let alone the one costing significantly more than some others.
This is compounded by the price/lack of availability so I've built them up to be something amazing because they are impossible to obtain.
I've tried one on and it's not as good as a few rivals in key areas but I still want one REALLY badly lol.