I had same issue with my Explorer I clasp and my local AD couldn't fix it.
Took it to the Rolex St.James and the technician lady fixed it right in front of eyes in less than a minute.
Your is probably the same issue where you are trying to put the clasp back on the end hole and I think you need to use the second from the end.
At least that's what I believe she did.
Sent from my SM-A520F using Tapatalk