Time to cull a diver from the collection

[Middo]

I only have two, a seiko mm300 sbdx 017 and Tudor Harrods black bay. I don’t wear divers that much and it’s time to let one go. If you could only keep one what would you choose?

[stefmcd]

That's quite a dilemma. Both v appealing. I'd keep em both. But gun to my head, the Seiko would go. Its height just makes it less versatile.

Sent from my CLT-L09 using Tapatalk

[Sc-texas]

The MM300

Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk

[Sinnlover]

I would shift the Harrods Black Bay. The MM300 is a fantastic watch.

[wildheart]

Neither my favourites sell the pair, buy a nice Omega SMP, much more wearable IMHO

[gbn13]

Sell both and buy a Black Bay 58.

[TaketheCannoli]

I do like both of yours OP but I agree with this comment about an SMP. I was looking at them the other day and there's some belters in the range.

Neither my favourites sell the pair, buy a nice Omega SMP, much more wearable IMHO

[wileeeeeey]

Ditch the Tudor.

Or sell both and get the SLA021 which is the new SBDX017 with sapphire crystal and ceramic bezel.

[Ghost Chilli]

Although both divers very different watches. I like both but probably wouldn't buy either, but only because there are plenty I prefer at that price range. You probably know deep down which one is the keeper but still a tough choice!

Enough waffle, which one do you wear the most? I find that's the only way to choose sometimes.

[Wallasey Runner]

Like others, I would ditch the Tudor, probably an easy sell as well.

[Montello]

Sell both and buy a Black Bay 58.

I'd agree with this; more modest case size making it more wearable.

[Bclark]

I'd keep the Harrods Black Bay

[MarkJS]

Ditch the Tudor.

[mjc1216]

Neither my favourites sell the pair, buy a nice Omega SMP, much more wearable IMHO

Can't disagree with that IMHO.

[Middo]

Ditch the Tudor.

Or sell both and get the SLA021 which is the new SBDX017 with sapphire crystal and ceramic bezel.

The SLA021 is a belter, my local AD has one in too. That said my 17 has a sapphire crystal fitted and I don't think its worth the extra to change.

[Middo]

Although both divers very different watches. I like both but probably wouldn't buy either, but only because there are plenty I prefer at that price range. You probably know deep down which one is the keeper but still a tough choice!

Enough waffle, which one do you wear the most? I find that's the only way to choose sometimes.

That's a good point, I have hardly worth them as I mostly wear GMTs for work. Will wack the Seiko on for a few days again with strap change. The tudor only got worn once thinking about it.

[Wyvern971]

That's a good point, I have hardly worth them as I mostly wear GMTs for work. Will wack the Seiko on for a few days again with strap change. The tudor only got worn once thinking about it.

Given that you've only worn the Tudor once, I'd ditch that.

However I guess it depends which you wear and like, if neither then maybe consider selling both?

Sent from my ONEPLUS A6003 using TZ-UK mobile app

[wileeeeeey]

The SLA021 is a belter, my local AD has one in too. That said my 17 has a sapphire crystal fitted and I don't think its worth the extra to change.

FWIW I wouldn't buy the SLA brand new. Not a chance. Via SC would be my preferred option.

[JP28]

If you do not need any money sell both and consolidate to something new :)

[Middo]

I wasn’t a fan if the sea master, however the new ceramic dialled variants are rather eye catching.