I have a white faced Zenith dress watch from the 90s I wore for my wedding, which I feel exactly the same about.
It looks great, very elegant; some horological interest with a super thin in house movement; and of course sentimental value. I should love it... but I don’t. Simply not a fan of dress watches.
I’ve tried to sell it a few times, but it’s always been withdrawn at the 11th hour - every collection needs a dress watch right? Plus this is the wedding watch.....
I wear it for a few days every once in a while, but I’m now resigned to never loving it and probably never selling it.