How about something a bit different.
Alfa Romeo Giulia. 2l 280hp but significantly lighter than competitors so 280 gives you 5.7 to 60 mph.
Despite the old “reliability” comments and history, it’s not the case today, they score better than the brands you’ve listed.
Beachdale Alfa in Derby area is one of the cheapest and also a family business.
I like mine so much more than my previous Audi A4 and past BMW’s.