Nothing bad about this Subaru. In fact, I dare say it's one of the best cars around. However, it's pretty thirsty compared with 2WD brands/models. but with 12K/yr. the difference between a thirsty 4x4 and a less thirsty 2WD isn't a real financial problem, I reckon. I am not a fan of cross climates. I drove a BMW 525 on CC's last Thursday and I found them to be noisy. But, that can be a brand issue (dunno what brand was used on the BMW). Summer T's and Winter T's would be my advice. Anyway, this might help: https://www.michelin.co.uk/tyres/car-tyres#type=type_2
Menno