Vintage Datejust vs vintage Grand Seiko
Apologies if this has been posted before but I found this interesting comparison of two similar but also very different watches, the DateJust 1603 and Grand Seiko 6245-9001.
https://adventuresinamateurwatchfett...s-grand-seiko/
I think both are great, timeless designs but I do have a preference for the GS because I love the bezel-free design and the hands look just deadly.
Both watches obviously have their modern equivalents in the current 36mm Datejust and the SBGR095 Historical Edition. I wonder what that comparison would reveal?
Vintage Datejust vs vintage Grand Seiko
Both beautiful. My take on it - in terms of the vintage pieces, it's a lot easier to find a decent example of the DJ than the GS, which has aged gracefully. There are just more of them, and more of those are better looked after, and perhaps the design was just less vulnerable to water ingress when left for too long. A bit of all three probably. The Rolex service network would have helped, and still does. Parts availability for GS of this era is not great, to say the least. It may also be a factor that culturally, the Japanese are often more inclined to buy a new one than lovingly restore the old model. The hiatus in the brand before its relaunch won't have helped either, in terms of regular servicing. However I can say that the 60s GS self-dater I have is keeping excellent time and feels rock solid.
In terms of the current version, they are very different beasts. The DJ has continually evolved. For me the design lost some of its appeal over the years as the case shape changed, and the indices became lume filled. Technically these may have been improvements, but I prefer the old school charm. At least the DJ41 seems to have landed, as a design, and feels like a sensible modern incarnation of the classic idea. No arguments with the improvements in the movements at least, and the service network certainly improves on mailing watches to Maidenhead to be sent to Japan for rather expensive refinishing, even if that works (AP will re-finish a Royal Oak for less).
Where the modern GS differs though is that it's a very faithful reproduction. In most cases I'm not keen on re-issues as they feel inauthentic, but GS is the exception. I was able to take a close look at one of these in SalonQP and it left a lasting impression, it's exquisite. I can't comment on the movement and I'll leave brand preferences aside, but it is a very special watch in person, though perhaps quite small for some. In summary, I'd take the vintage DJ but the modern GS.